More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
This is "Rank the Most Controversial," and today’s list will set the Westeros fandom ablaze. I’m counting down the top five most controversial Daenerys Targaryen moments that split the Game of Thrones online community. Fans battled across forums, social media, and comment sections, defending their Mother of Dragons or demanding her head on a spike. Whether you cheered her on or cursed the writers’ choices, these moments prove no Game of Thrones character fueled debates like Daenerys Stormborn.
Number five: Daenerys burns Kraznys mo Nakloz alive in Astapor and frees the Unsullied. In the third season, Daenerys negotiates with slaver Kraznys mo Nakloz for an army of Unsullied, offering up her dragon Drogon as payment. Instead of handing over a beast, she commands Drogon to burn Kraznys alive and orders the Unsullied to turn their weapons on the city’s masters. The newly freed Unsullied then choose to follow Daenerys, hailing her as “Mhysa.” This moment drew fierce admiration for her decisiveness and anti-slavery stance, but it also raised concerns online about the morality of mass execution without trial and the white savior narrative. Some fans argued the spectacle was empowering, while others thought it foreshadowed a future of violent rule. The debate centered on whether Daenerys’s actions were revolutionary justice or the beginning of tyrannical tendencies.
Number four: The execution of Randyll and Dickon Tarly with dragonfire in “The Spoils of War.” After defeating the Lannister and Tarly armies in a fiery ambush, Daenerys offers the surviving soldiers a choice: bend the knee or die. Randyll Tarly, and his son Dickon, refuse. Daenerys has Drogon execute them by fire. Fans clashed on this decision: some saw it as a necessary act of war, holding traitors accountable. Others thought burning prisoners alive was excessive, especially since Randyll was a respected noble and Dickon was just following his father’s lead. The moment sparked heated arguments over Daenerys’s sense of justice. Was she maintaining order, or did this signal an emerging cruelty? On social media, posts comparing her to her father, the “Mad King,” began gaining traction.
Number three: Daenerys’s romantic relationship with Jon Snow and the reveal of his true parentage. In season seven, Daenerys and Jon’s alliance against the Night King turns into romance, culminating in a pivotal scene aboard a ship. The revelation that Jon is actually Aegon Targaryen, her nephew, set the internet on fire. Some fans embraced the pairing as the ultimate power couple, while others recoiled at the incestuous implications and the sudden shift from political partners to lovers. The debate intensified as Jon’s Targaryen claim threatened Daenerys’s legitimacy, creating a split between those who wanted her as queen and those who preferred Jon. The discourse spilled into theories and speculation, with online polls and forums divided over who deserved the throne and whether their relationship was compelling or forced for drama.
Number two: Daenerys’s execution of Varys for treason in “The Bells.” As the power struggle for the Iron Throne intensifies, Varys attempts to rally support for Jon Snow, fearing Daenerys’s instability. Tyrion warns Daenerys of Varys’s betrayal, and she sentences Varys to die by dragonfire. This moment drew sharp criticism and justification in equal measure. Some fans believed Daenerys had no choice but to eliminate a traitor threatening her rule, while others argued she was too quick to execute a former loyal advisor who was acting in the realm’s best interest. The choice reignited arguments about Daenerys’s paranoia and whether she’d lost her moral compass. Online, viewers debated the fairness of Varys’s death and whether it was a logical escalation or an abrupt plot device to isolate Daenerys before the series end.
And now, number one: Daenerys’s decision to burn King’s Landing after the bells of surrender ring in “The Bells.” This is the most divisive moment in the character’s arc, and it’s not even close. As the city surrenders, Daenerys, atop Drogon, launches a devastating attack on the civilian population, incinerating streets, buildings, and countless innocents. Fan response was immediate and volcanic. Critics and audiences accused the showrunners—David Benioff and D. B. Weiss—of betraying years of character development. Many believed Daenerys’s turn to mass murder was unearned, arguing that her previous cruelties were always justified as justice against the wicked, not indiscriminate slaughter. Others defended the twist, citing her Targaryen lineage, isolation, and accumulated trauma as factors driving her to “let it be fear,” as Benioff and Weiss described in behind-the-scenes interviews.
The controversy reached its peak when a Change.org petition demanding HBO remake the eighth season “that makes sense” went viral, collecting over 1 million signatures within a week of “The Bells” airing. Fans vented anger at the show’s pacing, claiming Daenerys’s shift from liberator to destroyer happened too quickly to be believable. Critics like Lenika Cruz of The Atlantic called it “the worst Game of Thrones episode ever,” arguing that it was an “unearned negation of the identity [Daenerys] had spent years building.” Others, including Daniel D’Addario of Variety, insisted Daenerys’s turn fit her past “tactics... more deeply rooted in dominance than in empathy.” In interviews, Emilia Clarke, who played Daenerys, said, “Every single thing that’s led her to this point, and there she is, alone.”
On fan forums and social media, the debate raged between those who viewed Daenerys’s destruction of King’s Landing as tragic inevitability and those who saw it as character assassination. Some cited the Targaryen history of madness, while others argued that the show leaned too heavily on the trope of a powerful woman “going crazy.” The reaction was so intense that cast members responded: Isaac Hempstead Wright called the petition “ridiculous,” Jacob Anderson called it “rude,” and Sophie Turner argued that the backlash was “disrespectful to the crew, and the writers, and the filmmakers who have worked tirelessly over 10 years.”
The level of division over Daenerys’s ending is unmatched in Game of Thrones history. Rotten Tomatoes gave “The Bells” a 49% approval rating from critics, the second lowest in the series, and fans are still arguing about whether she was always destined for this fate or if she deserved better.
That’s the top five. Did I leave out your personal “dragons over Meereen” or “Mhysa” moment? Should burning the Tarlys be number one, or did the internet overreact to King’s Landing? Let me know your top controversial Daenerys moments, and bring your best arguments—this debate is far from over.