More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
If you were anywhere near the internet in early 2021, you probably remember the chaos around GameStop’s stock—the meme stock that suddenly became the hottest ticket on Wall Street. But behind the viral memes and the cries of “diamond hands” on r/WallStreetBets, there’s a darker side to the story: a saga of financial risk, community infighting, trading platform controversies, and dramatic real-life consequences for both small investors and billion-dollar hedge funds.
r/WallStreetBets is a subreddit founded in 2012 by Jaime Rogozinski. By 2026, it had nearly 20 million subscribers, known for their brash humor, risky trading, and a fondness for “YOLO” bets in the stock market. The community’s tagline, “Like 4chan found a Bloomberg terminal,” captures its irreverent and chaotic style. Members use unique slang—terms like “stonks” for stocks, “tendies” for gains, “diamond hands” for those who refuse to sell, and “paper hands” for those who give up quickly. There’s a sense of camaraderie and rebellion, with many members viewing themselves as underdogs taking on traditional Wall Street power.
GameStop, an American video game retailer, had struggled for years due to competition from digital sales and fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic. Its stock price slumped so much that, by early 2021, roughly 140 percent of its public float had been sold short—meaning more shares were borrowed and bet against than actually existed. This level of short interest is extremely rare and signaled to some that Wall Street was betting on GameStop’s demise.
In mid-2019, Keith Gill, also known as “DeepFuckingValue” on Reddit and “Roaring Kitty” on YouTube, bought around $53,000 in GameStop call options. By January 27, 2021, his position ballooned to $48 million. Gill, a 34-year-old marketing professional and CFA, posted regular updates on r/WallStreetBets, sharing both his research and his staggering gains and losses. His conviction—famously expressed when he said, “Yea there’s deep value, then there’s deep fucking value”—became a rallying cry.
The real momentum began in January 2021 after activist investor Ryan Cohen, co-founder of Chewy, joined GameStop’s board. As r/WallStreetBets users saw an opportunity to trigger a “short squeeze,” thousands jumped in. A short squeeze happens when those betting against a stock are forced to buy shares to cover their positions as prices rise, which in turn drives the price even higher. By January 27, GameStop’s stock soared to an intraday high of $483, up from $17.25 at the start of the month—a nearly 30-fold increase.
The subreddit exploded in popularity. On January 29, 2021, r/WallStreetBets gained 1.5 million users overnight, reaching a total of 6 million. Mashable reported 73 million page views in one day, breaking site records. The community was briefly set to private by moderators to handle the surge, and its Discord server was banned for “hateful and discriminatory content,” only to be reinstated after Discord staff stepped in to help with moderation tools.
But as the price shot upward, tension brewed. Many hedge funds faced catastrophic losses. Melvin Capital, a major GameStop short seller, lost 53 percent of its investments by the end of January 2021. Citadel and Point72 Asset Management invested $2.75 billion to stabilize Melvin, which ultimately shut down in 2022. Citron Research, led by Andrew Left, closed its short position at a complete loss and announced it would stop providing short-sell analysis altogether.
Yet, not everyone was winning. Many retail investors bought GameStop near its peak or held on as the price crashed. By February 2, GameStop’s price had dropped over 80 percent from its high, erasing about $27 billion in value. Some r/WallStreetBets users lost most of their savings, and reports surfaced of individuals left financially devastated after following the hype.
The chaos triggered a cascade of technical and regulatory issues. On January 28, Robinhood and other brokerages halted buying of GameStop and other volatile stocks, citing an inability to provide sufficient collateral to clearinghouses, which ensure that trades settle correctly. The Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation, one such clearinghouse, increased industrywide collateral requirements from $26 billion to $33.5 billion in response to unprecedented trading volume. These restrictions led to public outcry, class-action lawsuits, and accusations of market manipulation from politicians and commentators across the spectrum.
This is where the heart of the controversy lies: many r/WallStreetBets users saw the brokerage restrictions as Wall Street protecting its own at the expense of individual investors. Review bombing sank Robinhood’s app store ratings, and class-action lawsuits were filed. Some users alleged that the platforms sold their shares without consent—allegations which Robinhood denied. The issue of whether these firms acted fairly is still debated. Brokerages argued the restrictions were necessary to protect market stability, but many traders believed it was an unjust intervention that tilted the playing field.
The saga didn’t just impact GameStop. The frenzy spilled over to other heavily shorted stocks like AMC, Blackberry, Bed Bath & Beyond, and even companies like Koss Corporation, whose executives and directors made $45 million—more than the company’s entire 2020 valuation. Cryptocurrencies such as Dogecoin surged over 800 percent, and the price of silver futures rose by 10 percent over two days, although it remains unclear who was responsible for the metal rally.
Notably, a substantial portion of the market activity came from institutional investors, not just Reddit traders. Reuters and JP Morgan Chase both found that Wall Street’s largest asset managers realized gains both from share stakes and by lending out stocks to short sellers. Senvest Management, for example, bought a five percent stake in GameStop at $10 per share and exited with a $700 million profit after Elon Musk tweeted “Gamestonk!!” on January 26.
Some of the criticism surrounding the saga centers on the high-risk, gambling-like mentality promoted by the r/WallStreetBets community. The subreddit is notorious for stories of extreme wins and losses, with some users betting their student loans or life savings on meme stocks. While many participants understand the risks, there’s ongoing debate about whether the community’s culture encourages reckless behavior or simply empowers individuals to take control of their own financial destinies.
Another point of contention: was this really a grassroots victory for retail traders, or did it become a feeding frenzy for larger players who capitalized on the volatility? The influx of bots, institutional trading, and the eventual profit-taking by Wall Street funds muddy the narrative.
The GameStop saga also forced a conversation about regulation, market transparency, and the power of online communities to move markets. Congressional hearings were held, and dozens of lawsuits lingered in the aftermath.
Some believe the movement is a model for “people power” in finance, while others see it as a cautionary tale of market manipulation and herd mentality. Critics ask whether meme stock mania was a fluke, or if it exposed deeper flaws in how markets operate.
One open question remains: how should regulators respond to the power of online communities to move markets, and can future meme stock frenzies be prevented without undermining retail investors’ access?