More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
At 9:07 on the evening of June 17, 2015, a dispatcher in Charleston, South Carolina, received a description from a call about a shooting inside a church. The caller reported a young white man—and that he was reloading.
The church was Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal, widely known as Mother Emanuel. People had gathered there for Bible study. Nine would die. The man who shot them had sat among them for approximately an hour before opening fire.
This is a deeply disturbing story. We’ll follow what the records establish, from the church’s history to the calls for help, the search for the gunman, and the court cases. We won’t invent what anyone thought in their final moments. The people who were killed deserve more than that.
To understand why this place mattered, go back well before 2015. The congregation’s roots reach to a religious group organized by enslaved and free Black people in 1791. In 1816, Black members left a Charleston Methodist church after a dispute over burial ground and formed a separate congregation under Morris Brown’s leadership.
Its history includes state repression. Ministers were jailed under laws restricting independent Black worship. Authorities investigated the church during the controversy surrounding Denmark Vesey’s planned uprising against slavery, and the church was burned. When all-Black churches were outlawed in 1834, the congregation met in secret. It formally reorganized after the Civil War and took the name Emanuel.
By 2015, Mother Emanuel was the oldest AME church in the South. The building itself, dating from 1891, still held its original pews. This was a congregation whose members had sustained a place of worship through generations of attempts to deny them one.
The June attack was racist. The National Park Service describes all nine people killed as African American and calls it a racist attack. In a PBS discussion days afterward, a participant said the gunman wanted to start a race war. The same discussion noted that he had spoken to friends about his intentions.
That matters when tracing the lead-up, but it calls for care. Those warnings were not a minute-by-minute record of a settled plan, and they did not give the people at Bible study a way to know what was coming. Racist beliefs explain whom the gunman targeted; they do not make his decision inevitable.
One part of the lead-up is documented in unusual detail. On April 11, 2015, Dylann Roof tried to buy a handgun in West Columbia, South Carolina. The purchase triggered a federal background check.
An FBI examiner found a record of Roof’s March drug arrest. Further inquiry into the arrest could have stopped the sale: according to FBI Director James Comey’s later account, the police report recorded Roof admitting possession of drugs. But the criminal-history entry pointed the examiner toward the wrong sheriff’s office. A contact list then led her to West Columbia police rather than the Columbia police, who held the relevant report.
The check remained pending. On April 16, after the waiting period allowed by federal law, the dealer transferred the gun. Comey said plainly afterward that Roof should not have been allowed to buy it. This was not a background check that cleared him; it was a check that failed to reach a decision before the dealer proceeded.
Two months later, on Wednesday evening, June 17, people came to Mother Emanuel for Bible study. Among those present was the church’s pastor, the Reverend Clementa Pinckney, who was also a South Carolina state senator.
According to a Charleston police affidavit later reported by ABC News, Roof joined the study. After approximately an hour, he stood, drew a handgun and began shooting the people in the room. The affidavit says nine victims were struck. Police documents also describe him making a racist statement to a witness.
There is no need to fill the spaces between those documented facts with imagined dialogue. The sequence we can establish is already devastating: a guest was welcomed into a gathering, remained while the study continued, and then attacked the people around him.
Police logs give the next few minutes a stark rhythm. Calls about the shooting began reaching police at 9:05 p.m.; some came from inside the church. At 9:07, dispatchers received the description of a young white male reloading. By 9:09, authorities had learned that witnesses were still alive, including people hiding under a desk in the pastor’s office.
At 9:11, the logs indicated the shooting was over and the gunman had fled. Eight people had been killed; a ninth would die shortly afterward.
Those times are the times recorded in calls and dispatch logs—not a complete account of every movement inside the room. They show something else clearly: while the attacker was still there, people inside and outside the church were trying to get help to those under fire.
The nine people killed were Reverend Clementa Pinckney, Tywanza Sanders, Cynthia Hurd, Reverend Sharonda Coleman-Singleton, Myra Thompson, Ethel Lance, Reverend Daniel Simmons, Reverend DePayne Middleton-Doctor, and Susie Jackson.
Their names interrupt the perpetrator’s story, as they should. They were people gathered for study and fellowship, not an anonymous count. In the immediate aftermath, investigators faced a practical question alongside the enormity of the loss: the gunman had escaped. How could they identify him before he hurt anyone else?
Investigators released photographs taken from surveillance video. Roof’s father and uncle recognized both him and his car and contacted Charleston police, according to the police documents reported by ABC News. Other people also called with his name. Around six the next morning, one caller said he was certain he knew the man in the released images and supplied details about his vehicle.
The trail led to Shelby, North Carolina. Police reports there describe officers encountering Roof’s Hyundai Elantra and detaining him. They recorded that he indicated he understood why he had been stopped; he also told officers there was a gun in the back seat.
It was not one miraculous clue that identified him. Publicly released images, people willing to call police—including his relatives—and the search for his car brought the manhunt to an end the day after the shooting.
The criminal proceedings took years, and there were two jurisdictions. In December 2016, a federal jury convicted Roof on 33 charges connected to the massacre, including hate crimes. In January 2017, that jury chose a federal death sentence.
South Carolina pursued its own case. On April 10, 2017, Roof pleaded guilty to state murder charges and received nine consecutive life sentences without parole. He also received 90 years for three counts of attempted murder. The state prosecutor described the plea to families as an insurance policy: even if the federal death sentence were overturned, the state sentences would keep him in prison for life.
A verdict can establish responsibility and impose punishment. It cannot restore the lives taken in that room, or remove what witnesses and families lived through afterward.
The massacre also forced public decisions beyond the courtroom. South Carolina removed the Confederate flag from its State House grounds after the shooting. The FBI director publicly explained the background-check failure and ordered a review. Those responses addressed different questions—how a racist symbol was displayed by the state, and how a gun sale went ahead when crucial arrest information had not reached an examiner. Neither should be mistaken for an explanation that makes the murders less deliberate.
The enduring image of June 17 is not the gunman’s escape or even his capture the following day. It is a congregation with a long history of gathering despite hostility, meeting once more for Bible study. The account ends with nine names, and with the responsibility for their deaths placed where the courts placed it: on Dylann Roof.