More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
What happens when a YouTuber trying to expose sexual predators gets banned by the very platform he’s trying to protect? That’s exactly the chaos that erupted in August 2025 when Roblox—one of the world’s biggest gaming platforms for kids—permanently banned Schlep, a creator whose entire channel was built around catching alleged predators on Roblox itself, then sent him a legal threat to stop his work or face a lawsuit.
So who are the players at the heart of this drama? On one side, you have Schlep, a Texas-based YouTuber. Before 2025, Schlep was just another Roblox fan, posting videos—sometimes about Roblox’s problems, sometimes about building elaborate parks in the game Theme Park Tycoon 2. But everything changed when, after hearing complaints from fans about predators targeting minors on Roblox, Schlep began orchestrating sting operations. His method: create decoy accounts posing as minors, lure would-be predators into explicit conversations, then pass those messages to local police. By the time the controversy exploded, Schlep had documented six arrests in his videos; in one case, a 21-year-old man was caught after two months of online chats and an attempted in-person meetup. Only one of the six was not charged.
But the real twist? Schlep’s drive came from personal history. He said he was groomed by a Roblox developer at age twelve—a traumatic experience that led to a suicide attempt. When his mother reported it, nothing happened. That betrayal shaped his crusade. He started working with groups like “EDP Watch” and “Predator Poachers,” and even collaborated with police in Arkansas and the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, though law enforcement themselves stayed quiet about these links.
By 2025, Schlep had become a lightning rod. His channel’s audience grew, and the stings kept coming. He openly criticized Roblox on social media, blasting the company for what he saw as a failure to ban dangerous users and moderate inappropriate games—issues that, as his lawyer later noted, had plagued the platform for nearly twenty years.
Then, on August 9, 2025, came the ban. Roblox Corporation didn’t just ban Schlep’s main account—they terminated all his accounts and barred him from creating new ones. Within hours, Schlep posted a photo of the cease and desist letter he received: Roblox accused him of violating their new “vigilante groups” rule, interfering with official investigations, and breaching user privacy. The letter threatened legal action if he resumed any part of his sting operations or tried to access Roblox again.
Schlep uploaded an eight-minute video called “Roblox Is Threatening to Sue Me For Protecting Kids.” He recounted his own abuse at twelve, and said local police had thanked him for his help catching predators. He made it clear: he’d never use Roblox again unless allowed, but he’d keep running sting operations on his own website. He described Roblox’s legal threats as “laughably hilarious.”
The reaction was instant and explosive. The hashtag #freeschlep began trending, with players, parents, and even some popular creators rallying to Schlep’s defense. Roblox YouTubers like Kindly Keyin and ThinkNoodles quit the platform’s content program in protest. Big names in the gaming commentary world—Cr1TiKaL, JiDion, and KreekCraft—called Roblox’s move “backwards” and “hypocritical.” Other developers quietly altered their in-game icons and thumbnails to say “FREE SCHLEP.” In Roblox itself, players changed their display names and staged digital protests, spamming “Free Schlep” in chat.
Even Chris Hansen, host of “To Catch a Predator,” weighed in. On August 22, he appeared in a YouTube video with Schlep, announcing a forthcoming documentary on child safety and Roblox’s predator problem. By August 19, a petition started by Congressman Ro Khanna was nearing 100,000 signatures; its goal was a million signatures urging Roblox to “do more” to protect children. The uproar spilled into the real world—an online streamer known as Steak, with three million followers, staged a live protest at the Utah Capitol, holding up “Free Schlep” signs for tens of thousands of online viewers. Some players even called for Roblox’s CEO to resign.
Roblox Corporation, under siege, finally issued a statement. They said the problem wasn’t just Schlep but “vigilante groups” in general. According to Roblox, these groups made things worse by moving conversations off-site and impersonating minors, which they argued normalized inappropriate conduct. The company insisted that these tactics interfered with legitimate police investigations and risked making vigilantes as dangerous as the people they were trying to expose. Roblox’s head of security, Matt Kaufman, posted a video describing Schlep’s actions as “vigilantism.” He claimed the right way to address abuse was always through official channels.
Schlep, naturally, rejected their framing. In interviews, he said he never “took the law into his own hands,” and had always wanted to work with Roblox—that is, until he lost faith in their reporting system. He revealed that he’d reached out to Roblox’s leadership in the past for help, but got no reply. When Roblox CEO David Baszucki was asked about the ban on CNBC, Baszucki said he wanted to add new safety measures and even reached out to Schlep for feedback. Schlep’s legal team called this “a PR stunt,” sending Roblox a letter warning that the outreach ignored his prior attempts to collaborate.
Legal threats started piling up on both sides. On August 15, Schlep hired lawyers and spoke publicly about countersuing Roblox. Stinar Gould Grieco & Hensley, the law firm representing him, said they had more than 500 clients with similar stories of abuse on Roblox. A YouTuber and lawyer with over 14 million subscribers, Law by Mike, joined Schlep’s legal team in September. Meanwhile, the attorney general of Louisiana, Liz Murrill, sued Roblox over child safety failures, directly tying her lawsuit to this controversy. In October, politician Russell Coleman announced another lawsuit, stating, “Roblox is even trying to silence those who raised these security risks. The famous case of one of their developers, Schlep, immediately comes to mind.”
The impact didn’t stop there. Popular third-party developers threatened to walk away. National media outlets—from Rolling Stone to The Washington Post—ran stories questioning the safety of Roblox’s 65 million daily users, most of them children. Players, parents, and content creators were locked in debate: Was Schlep a reckless vigilante risking kids’ privacy and criminal cases, or a necessary whistleblower when the system fails? The only thing certain was that neither side trusted the other—and that the fight for control over digital safety had shifted into the public eye.
One thing remains unresolved: will Roblox ever find a way to work with independent watchdogs like Schlep, or will the company’s crackdown only drive more creators—and more controversy—underground?