More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
This ranking is going to get people talking, because few celebrity feuds have inspired as many arguments, memes, think-pieces, and subtweets as the ongoing drama between Selena Gomez and Hailey Bieber. With two of the most-followed women on Instagram, legions of loyal fans, and years of tabloid speculation, every small update sets fandoms ablaze.
At number 5: Hailey Bieber’s 2023 Statement on Mental Health and Online Rumors
In April 2023, Hailey Bieber issued a public statement about her mental health, revealing she had been "fragile" since the beginning of the year. She mentioned experiencing "some of the saddest, hardest moments" and feeling "fragile," but did not directly reference the feud with Selena Gomez as the cause. This admission, delivered in a statement and a 12-minute YouTube video, put her personal struggle in the spotlight and forced even casual onlookers to confront the toll that public scrutiny and online rumors were taking.
Fans argued over this moment for two main reasons. First, some saw it as Hailey finally speaking out and humanizing herself in the middle of a storm of criticism. Others, however, accused her of deflecting or seeking sympathy, rather than addressing specific incidents or clearing the air with Gomez directly. The debate over whether celebrities should engage with or ignore online drama only intensified, with both fandoms dissecting every word for hidden meaning.
Number 4: Hailey Bieber’s Church Connection and Its Role in the Feud Narrative
Hailey Bieber was raised as an evangelical Christian, while Gomez has described herself as Catholic and previously referenced her religious upbringing. This difference in backgrounds, which might seem benign, became controversial online because of frequent speculation about friend circles, loyalty, and the ways church-based social groups overlap with entertainment industry networks.
Fans latched onto the religious connection as a source of indirect drama, theorizing about divided social circles and secret allegiances. Some insisted the shared faith should unite rather than divide, while others saw it as another layer of coded messages and subtle power plays. Every piece of background information gets pulled into the wider feud narrative, and the church connection became a recurring talking point in online debates.
Number 3: The Skincare Wars—Rhode Versus Rare Beauty
On June 15, 2022, Hailey Bieber launched Rhode, her skincare brand, after months of anticipation. Selena Gomez, meanwhile, had already founded Rare Beauty, a cosmetics brand valued at $2 billion. The launch of Rhode set the stage for a business rivalry that fans immediately linked to the ongoing personal feud.
Controversy erupted around the overlap—Was Rhode copying Rare, or was every celebrity skincare line inevitably similar? When e.l.f. acquired Rhode for $1 billion in May 2025, the business stakes of this rivalry became clear. Some fans applauded Hailey’s business acumen, while others accused her of riding on trends started by Gomez. The fact that both women oversee their brands as chief creative officers only fueled speculation about whose vision was truly original and whose products were more authentic. The business dimension of their feud brought new arguments to the fanbase, with every product launch and marketing campaign scrutinized for hidden jabs.
Number 2: The Marriage—Hailey and Justin Bieber’s Engagement and Wedding Timelines
Hailey Bieber married Justin Bieber in 2018 after a rapid engagement, following a brief earlier relationship in late 2015 and a reconciliation in June 2018. This timeline quickly became one of the most controversial topics in both fandoms, largely because of Justin Bieber’s prior long-term, public relationship with Selena Gomez. The Biebers announced their engagement in July 2018 and confirmed their marriage in November, holding a second wedding ceremony on September 30, 2019, in South Carolina.
Fans of Gomez and Bieber both debated the implications of the timeline—was it too soon? Did the relationship overlap? Was there lingering drama? Every social media post, paparazzi photo, and offhand comment was dissected for clues. The controversy only grew when Hailey and Justin announced the birth of their son on August 23, 2024, with fans on both sides alternately congratulating and scrutinizing the couple’s every move.
Number 1: The Alleged Social Media Subtweets, Likes, and Unfollows
No moment has divided fans more than the endless cycle of alleged subtweets, cryptic Instagram stories, likes, unfollows, and refollowings between Selena Gomez and Hailey Bieber. Even without explicit statements, fans have tracked timelines, screen-capped posts before they disappear, and debated the meaning behind every emoji, selfie, and playlist update.
This controversy is so heated because it’s fueled almost entirely by speculation, interpretation, and the amplification power of social media itself. Every time either Gomez or Bieber posts or deletes something, armies of fans interpret it as a coded message, a dig, or an olive branch. The lack of direct statements only makes the debates fiercer, with some insisting that every move is deliberate and others claiming it’s all coincidence or fan overreach.
The number one spot goes to these micro-moments because they exemplify what makes this feud so controversial—the way in which social media not only documents but actively shapes the narrative. Entire communities have sprung up to analyze the subtext, and both women’s follower counts—Gomez is recognized as the most-followed woman on Instagram—mean that every action instantly becomes global news. There’s no single event to point to, just a rolling wave of speculation, reaction, and debate.