More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
You can still find screenshots from the Tana Mongeau and Jake Paul feud circulating on influencer meme accounts today, and there’s a reason people keep coming back. Their Instagram drama wasn’t just about two creators trading jabs – it was a high-speed collision between influencer fandom, blurred reality, and intense community infighting. Tana Mongeau and Jake Paul each had millions of followers before they ever partnered up – and when they did, the internet watched every move. People loved their online personas for different reasons: Tana for her unfiltered storytime rants and willingness to address controversy head-on, Jake for his wild prankster energy and larger-than-life Team 10 universe. Together, they built a spectacle that fans and critics couldn’t turn away from.
That spectacle peaked in July 2019, when Tana Mongeau and Jake Paul held a splashy wedding ceremony in Las Vegas. The event was broadcast as a $50 pay-per-view and filmed for MTV No Filter: Tana Turns 21. According to InTouch, the couple hadn’t actually obtained a marriage license, and the officiant wasn’t legally allowed to conduct marriages in Nevada. The wedding, which drew thousands of online viewers, wasn’t legally binding. Jake and Tana left the venue separately. BuzzFeed reported on the confusion and skepticism it generated, as fans and commentators openly questioned whether the relationship was genuine or just for content.
The doubts grew because both creators had a long history of blurring the line between real life and internet performance. Tana’s YouTube channel, launched in 2015, had already amassed over 5.5 million subscribers and nearly a billion views by early 2026. Her “storytime” videos often recounted personal drama, breakups, and feuds – sometimes in explicit detail, and always with her signature chaotic delivery. Jake Paul built his brand with Team 10, viral pranks, and manufactured social-media spectacle. When the two got together in April 2019, fans from both camps started speculating about motives, authenticity, and whether the couple was manipulating the audience.
The tension between their fandoms exploded on Instagram in the weeks leading up to the wedding. Both creators posted photos and stories hyping up their relationship, showing off matching tattoos, luxury trips, and behind-the-scenes glimpses of planning the event. Comments sections filled with rival fans accusing each other’s idol of clout-chasing or lying for attention. Many of Jake’s supporters argued that Tana was using the relationship to boost her status, pointing to her MTV show and recent music releases, including “FaceTime” and “Without You.” Tana’s fans pushed back, accusing Jake’s audience of misogyny and double standards, especially when old controversies were dredged up.
The underlying problem was that their relationship became a battleground for fandom identity. Supporters and detractors each staked their reputations on proving whether the romance was staged. The public split in January 2020 only intensified those arguments. Tana later said on her MTV show that the wedding was “fun and lighthearted” and something they were “obviously doing for fun and for content.” For some fans, this was confirmation that the whole spectacle had been a performance. For others, it was just another twist in a genuinely complicated relationship.
The feud spilled beyond just the couple and their followers. By turning their relationship into public content, Jake and Tana pulled in a massive cross-section of influencer culture. When TanaCon collapsed in June 2018—just a year before the wedding—her critics cited it as evidence that she was addicted to drama and couldn’t organize responsibly. Jake’s own career had included legal disputes, pranks gone wrong, and a string of public fallouts with fellow creators. Each new conflict became ammo for rival fans to attack or defend their chosen star across Instagram, YouTube, and Twitter. The wedding, split, and subsequent Instagram stories poured gasoline on those old fires.
The impact went far beyond internet beef. The fan wars had real-world consequences for everyone swept up in their orbit. Smaller creators who expressed opinions on the drama sometimes faced mass-reporting campaigns. Instagram meme pages covering the feud saw dramatic follower spikes, but also waves of harassment and doxing threats when they took sides. In the days after the wedding, “#JanaIsFake” and “#JanaForever” both trended on social platforms, with hundreds of thousands of posts attached. For Tana, the constant scrutiny affected her business ventures, like her wine brand Dizzy Wine, which launched in January 2022 and was flooded with reviews referencing the relationship. Jake saw similar backlash, with critics dissecting every new Team 10 member and collaboration for signs of orchestrated drama.
The criticism over their Instagram feud was often justified – but just as often, it spiraled into speculation without proof. Some fans argued that the lack of a marriage license and Tana’s own statements were clear evidence of a publicity stunt. Others pointed out that both had a long history of real relationships and personal struggles documented online, making it impossible to know what was staged and what was sincere. The feud also exposed a broader problem with influencer culture: the relentless pressure to produce content, even at the cost of personal boundaries or emotional fallout.
Community debate hasn’t died down. Supporters of Tana Mongeau argue that she’s always been transparent about her flaws and her use of drama in content. Detractors claim that she manipulates fan emotions for clout and leaves a trail of collateral damage. Jake Paul’s defenders say he’s just playing the game everyone else is, but on a larger scale, while his critics see his approach as emblematic of everything toxic about Instagram influencer circles. Both sides point to specific incidents – like the wedding, the split, and the subsequent string of Instagram stories – as proof that they’re right. Even now, people argue over whether fans themselves are complicit, egging on the drama in exchange for new memes and content.
The community is still locked in debate over what, if anything, should change. Some call for more transparency from creators when relationships are used as content. Others argue that fans should take more personal responsibility for the intensity and spread of online beef. Some want Instagram to introduce stricter moderation to curb harassment during these public flareups, while others warn that any intervention risks stifling the chaotic, unscripted energy that draws millions of people to influencer culture in the first place.
So, after all this, one question sticks: In a world where the line between content and reality is always shifting, can influencer fandoms ever escape the cycle of public spectacle and private fallout – or is that just the price everyone pays for playing the game?