More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
Welcome to “The Dark Side of the Clean Girl Aesthetic.” If you’ve scrolled through TikTok in the last few years, you’ve seen it: slicked-back buns, dewy skin, gold hoops, and minimalist routines promising effortless beauty and productivity. The clean girl aesthetic isn’t just a trend—it’s a digital lifestyle that’s pulled in millions, promising that with just the right routine, anyone can look and feel put together. But behind the glossy videos and endless product recommendations, a deeper debate is unfolding—one that touches on cultural appropriation, exclusion, and the pressures of perfection.
Let’s start with why so many people love the clean girl aesthetic. This trend exploded on TikTok in late 2021, then truly caught fire throughout 2022. Its appeal is built around simplicity, wellness, and control. The clean girl look is all about natural beauty: luminous skin, subtle glossy lips, minimal makeup, and simple, smart clothing in neutral tones. Pilates, early-morning routines, and green smoothies round out the lifestyle. The aesthetic slots neatly into the broader “That Girl” movement, which centers on productivity, self-care, and an outward image of professional and personal success.
On TikTok alone, the #CleanGirl hashtag has appeared on over 1.2 million videos as of February 2026. Influencers share tutorials, day-in-the-life vlogs, and product hauls, making the look feel achievable—and aspirational. Viewers see creators waking up at dawn, fitting in workouts, blending healthy breakfasts, and layering five or more skincare products before logging on to work or study. The format is immersive, personal, and algorithmically amplified—TikTok’s recommendation engine ensures that once you like or save a few videos, your feed fills with more of the same. The aesthetic’s promise is seductive: look put together, feel good, and succeed, all while appearing as if you’ve barely tried.
But here’s where the tension starts to show. As the clean girl trend exploded, so did criticism and controversy—especially around issues of cultural appropriation and exclusion. Critics noticed that many of the “signature” clean girl style elements—like slicked-back buns, thick brows, and brown lip liner—have deep roots in communities of color, especially among Black and Latina women. Yet, when these styles were worn by women from those communities for decades, they were often stigmatized as “unprofessional” or “ghetto.” Suddenly, when popularized by white influencers, those same looks were rebranded as chic and “clean.”
A flashpoint came in September 2022, when Hailey Bieber posted her “brownie glazed lips” tutorial, using a brown lip liner and gloss. Black and Latina creators called out the trend, pointing out that this style had long been a staple in their communities—yet only now did it gain mainstream praise and magazine coverage. TikTok creator @benulus summed up the frustration: “A white woman does it—it’s going to become a trend. It’s going to be praised.” The pattern wasn’t new, but TikTok’s massive reach and viral cycles made the contrast even starker.
Why did this happen? Part of the answer lies in TikTok’s design. Its algorithm creates filter bubbles, repeatedly surfacing similar content to users who interact with a trend. As a result, the “clean girl” look became less of a diverse style and more of a uniform—one that prioritized Eurocentric features and slim, toned bodies, often to the exclusion of anyone who didn’t fit the mold. Generative AI tools, trained on biased data, started to reinforce these narrow standards by erasing diverse features and amplifying Western beauty norms.
Health risks became another layer of the story. A Northwestern University study found that TikTok skincare routines—often involving multiple products and steps—sometimes expose teens to allergens and irritants, causing real skin damage. Products like Dior’s Lip Glow Oil were promoted as essentials by clean girl influencers, but reports in May 2025 showed the product could cause lip discoloration, especially among Black women. Some users described their lips turning black after prolonged use, highlighting how viral trends can have unforeseen consequences, particularly for women of color.
The pressure to perfect these routines, and to look “effortlessly” flawless, can be relentless. Critics argue that the clean girl aesthetic doesn’t just set a high bar for appearance—it frames identity as something to be visually managed and optimized. Skincare routines balloon to five or more steps, often featuring expensive anti-aging and anti-blemish products. Hair must be slick, shiny, and controlled. Clothing is restricted to a palette of whites, blacks, and grays, intended to “remove distractions” and keep the focus on the wearer’s face and body. Pilates is the preferred workout, and bodies are expected to be slim, toned, but not too muscular or curvy.
This focus on constant optimization has led commentators to accuse the clean girl trend of promoting unattainable standards. The aesthetic’s emphasis on self-policing—waking up early, eating the right foods, working out, and documenting it all—can create an atmosphere where women feel they must always be improving, managing, and presenting themselves for approval. The trend’s popularity has coincided with a noted decline in body positivity messaging online. Critics warn that it’s harder to find content celebrating diverse body types or natural imperfections when the algorithm keeps pushing a single, polished ideal.
Who is most affected? Marginalized communities, particularly women of color, bear the brunt of both the erasure and the exclusion. When Black and Latina women see their beauty rituals and styles repackaged and celebrated only when worn by white women, it reinforces patterns of cultural theft and double standards. The same practices that once drew ridicule or discrimination become aspirational—so long as the “right” people are presenting them. Furthermore, AI tools and the TikTok algorithm often give greater reach to creators who match the clean girl template, marginalizing those who don’t fit or who challenge the norm.
Is the criticism fair? The debate isn’t one-sided. Some argue that the clean girl aesthetic empowers women to invest in their well-being and presents a break from heavy makeup and unsustainable trends. For many, the routines are genuinely helpful, offering structure and a focus on self-care. But the criticism rests on more than personal preference. The rapid co-opting of marginalized beauty practices, combined with the exclusionary effects of algorithmic amplification, raises real questions about representation and equity. The health risks tied to popularized routines and products add a further layer of concern, especially when those risks disproportionately affect people of color.
Inside the community, the debate is ongoing. Some users and creators have pushed back, starting “de-influencing” movements in early 2023. These creators advise viewers to reject overhyped products and embrace mindful consumption, challenging the perfectionist ideals of the clean girl wave. Others demand more credit for the Black and Brown originators of style staples now deemed “clean.” Meanwhile, defenders of the trend argue that anyone can adapt its routines to fit their own background and identity, if the aesthetic remains open and inclusive.
There’s also a growing conversation about the role of platforms and algorithms. Does TikTok have a responsibility to surface more diverse content, or to address the bias embedded in its recommendation system and AI-powered filters? Should brands be held accountable when products promoted as “universal” cause harm to particular groups? And can any digital trend, built on the logic of virality and perfection, avoid excluding those who don’t—or can’t—fit the mold?
The clean girl aesthetic was never just about beauty; it’s a lens onto issues of race, technology, commerce, and identity in the social media age. As the debate continues, one question looms: can the clean girl trend evolve into something genuinely inclusive, or will it remain another fleeting standard that leaves too many people out?