More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
On May 6, 2013, a woman called 911 from a neighbor’s phone in Cleveland. She gave her name: Amanda Berry. She said she had been kidnapped and missing for ten years. Now she was free.
Amanda had made it out of a house on Seymour Avenue with her young daughter. But two other women were still inside. Police arrived within minutes, forced their way in and found Michelle Knight and Gina DeJesus—women whose families had also spent years searching for them.
The three had disappeared separately. All three had been held in that house by Ariel Castro. To understand how they got out, we have to go back to how each of them got in.
In August 2002, Michelle Knight was on her way to a social-services appointment concerning custody of her young son. She stopped at a dollar store to ask for directions. Castro, whom she recognized as a friend’s father, offered her a ride. She accepted. According to Knight’s later account, he took her to his home instead, restrained her and held her there.
Michelle was an adult when she disappeared. Her family initially reported her missing, but she was eventually presumed to have run away. She was not away by choice.
Eight months later, on April 21, 2003, sixteen-year-old Amanda Berry finished a shift at Burger King. It was the day before her birthday. She, too, knew Castro as a friend’s father. She accepted a ride from him and vanished.
Their families kept looking. Posters went up; pleas for information continued. Amanda’s mother, Louwana Miller, searched for her daughter for years. She died in 2006, never knowing that Amanda was alive.
In January 2004, police went to Castro’s house for an unrelated reason: child-welfare officials had reported that Castro, then a school-bus driver, had apparently left a child unattended on a bus. No one answered the door. Officers later spoke with him and determined there was no criminal intent in that incident. The visit did not reveal the women inside.
Then, in April 2004, fourteen-year-old Gina DeJesus disappeared while walking home from school. Gina was friends with Castro’s daughter. Castro abducted her, too. Three women were now captive in the same Cleveland house, only a few miles from where Michelle and Amanda had last been seen.
The years inside were not one continuous, knowable sequence of days. What survivors later described, and what investigators documented, was sustained confinement and abuse. Castro kept the women locked in rooms and subjected them to repeated sexual assault, beatings and deprivation of food and other necessities.
Amanda gave birth to a daughter, Jocelyn, while captive. Michelle told investigators that Castro forced her to help deliver the baby and threatened her if the child died. She also reported that he had made her pregnant repeatedly and assaulted and starved her to end those pregnancies. These are deeply disturbing facts, but they matter to understanding the crimes for which Castro would later be charged. They are not details the women owed the public.
Outside, the searches went on. The FBI worked with local authorities, followed leads and helped publicize the disappearances. Yet the house remained undiscovered as the place where the women were being held. The eventual breakthrough would begin with Amanda herself.
On May 6, 2013, Castro left the house. Jocelyn, then six years old, noticed he was gone. Amanda found something else unusual: her bedroom door had been left unlocked. She went downstairs with Jocelyn and reached the front of the house.
The first door opened. The storm door did not. It was padlocked. Amanda could get an arm outside, but she could not simply walk out. She shouted for help.
A neighbor, Charles Ramsey, heard her. He helped break through the lower part of the door, creating an opening large enough for Amanda to get out with her daughter. Both Ramsey and Amanda called 911.
This was the decisive moment in the case. Amanda had seized an opportunity, but she was not yet finished: she told the arriving officers that two more women were inside.
Officers Anthony Espada and Michael Tracy reached Seymour Avenue. They saw Amanda and Jocelyn outside. Tracy later said Amanda looked like the girl on the missing-person posters, only older. Espada recognized her eyebrow piercing.
The officers tried the entrance to Castro’s home and found it chained from inside. Tracy kicked at the door until it gave way. Police went upstairs, announcing themselves.
Michelle heard them. In an interview years later, she recalled seeing a badge and running into an officer’s arms. Gina did not come out immediately. She said she was so shocked that she initially wondered whether the people in the hallway were merely dressed as police officers. When she emerged, an officer asked her name. She told him: Georgina DeJesus.
The radio message from inside was simple: they had found them. After nearly eleven years for Michelle, ten for Amanda and nine for Gina, all three were out of the house.
Police still had to find Castro. Michelle provided a photograph of him from the house, and officers looked for the blue Mazda Miata he was believed to be driving. They found the car, pulled it over and arrested him. An officer then told the women he was in custody.
The survivors and Jocelyn received medical attention and were reunited with family. Gina’s mother, Nancy Ruiz, was nearby when she learned her daughter had been found. Gina had kept a missing-person flyer showing her own face—a flyer Castro had acquired and given her during captivity. She showed it to her mother when they met again.
The discoveries inside the house began a criminal investigation, not a sudden explanation for every unanswered question of the previous decade. Officers described dark rooms, chains and openings through which food had been passed. Investigators had to examine the scene and listen to the women’s accounts. Castro’s two brothers were initially detained, but police said there was no indication they knew about the captivity; they were cleared of wrongdoing in this case.
In July 2013, Castro pleaded guilty to an amended indictment containing 937 charges, including kidnapping, rape and aggravated murder. The aggravated-murder charge concerned a pregnancy ended by force; it did not mean that Michelle, Amanda or Gina had been killed. All three had survived.
At sentencing, Castro tried to recast what had happened. He denied torturing or raping the women and said there had been “harmony” in the house. Those claims stood in stark contrast to his guilty plea and the survivors’ accounts. Michelle addressed him directly in court: “You took 11 years of my life away, and now I have got it back.”
The judge sentenced Castro to life without parole, plus one thousand years. His house was demolished that August. On September 3, 2013, Castro died by suicide in prison.
There was no detective’s last-minute deduction that opened the door on Seymour Avenue. Amanda Berry noticed that her room was unlocked. She moved toward an exit, called to a neighbor and told police who else was inside. The officers acted on what she said; Michelle Knight and Gina DeJesus were found.
The criminal case ended with Castro’s guilty plea, sentence and death. The women’s lives did not end there, and their years of captivity cannot be reduced to the man who held them. At the moment of rescue, Gina, Michelle and Amanda each had a name she had spent years waiting for the world to hear again. This time, someone heard.