More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
Today on "The Dark Side of K-Pop Fandoms," we’re pulling back the curtain on the BTS ARMY—a community that millions around the world call home, but one that’s also faced its share of internal controversy and criticism.
To start, you have to understand why the BTS ARMY is one of the most admired and talked-about fanbases on the planet. BTS, the South Korean boy band that debuted in 2013, quickly built a reputation for deeply personal music, global charisma, and an ability to connect across cultures. Their fans—who call themselves the ARMY—aren’t just supporters. They’re organized, passionate, and committed to more than just music charts. ARMYs coordinate streaming parties to boost BTS’s positions on international rankings, trend hashtags that reach millions within hours, and collectively donate to charitable causes. In 2020, for example, ARMYs matched BTS's $1 million donation to Black Lives Matter in less than 24 hours, demonstrating the group’s global impact and the power of its fandom.
But beneath this story of unity and activism, a tension has been growing—a tension that cuts to the heart of what it means to be a “family” in a fandom this size. The ARMY’s reputation for overwhelming loyalty sometimes tips into overzealousness. Incidents as far back as April 2017 forced BTS’s management to increase security after a member was pursued by fans at Seoul's Gimpo International Airport. The intensity of some fans’ devotion was even described by one observer as “10/10 best horror movie of the year,” referencing the chaos that unfolded during these chases. By 2021, reports emerged from BTS concerts—like the “Permission to Dance on Stage” event in Los Angeles—of fan-on-fan violence, including an assault by a fansite photographer on a fellow ARMY. These moments exposed a darker side to the community: aggressive pursuit, harassment, and even physical altercations among fans.
Within the ARMY, the most significant internal controversy has centered on issues of racism and exclusion. In May 2018, Black BTS fans started using the hashtag #BlackARMYsMatter to highlight racism and harassment they experienced from other fans. This wasn’t a one-off incident; it was the result of persistent microaggressions, exclusion from fan activities, and a lack of support from mainstream ARMY spaces. The movement wasn’t just about telling personal stories—it was an organized campaign to force a conversation about discrimination in what was supposed to be an inclusive global community.
#BlackARMYsMatter became a rallying point for marginalized voices within the fandom. Black ARMY members spoke out about being silenced or mocked when they discussed their experiences, sometimes being told they were “ruining the mood” or “bringing negativity” to the fandom. The conversation spread rapidly, sparking broader debates about inclusivity not just in the BTS fandom, but across K-pop communities worldwide. The movement challenged the mainstream perception of ARMY as a universally welcoming and supportive space. Instead, it revealed fractures—spaces where racism, colorism, and xenophobia could and did occur.
As these accusations gained attention, parts of the fandom responded with defensiveness or denial. Some ARMY members argued that racism was not “their problem,” or claimed that the examples being cited were isolated incidents. Others pointed to BTS’s own repeated statements about the importance of diversity and acceptance. The group has publicly expressed appreciation for their global audience many times and, as recently as June 13, 2026, marked their 13th anniversary by thanking fans from around the world, continuing to celebrate the international diversity of the ARMY.
But institutional and cultural change inside the fandom has been slower than public statements might suggest. As of the most recent reporting, the hashtag #BlackARMYsMatter is still in use, and ongoing discussions about microaggressions, exclusion, and the need for better moderation in fan spaces continue to attract both support and backlash. In May 2024, another dimension of ARMY activism became visible: thousands of fans demanded accountability from HYBE, BTS’s management company, over controversies involving the group and internal company disputes. This marked a turning point where fans started seeing themselves not just as supporters, but as advocates responsible for the well-being of both BTS and their own community.
The question of who is affected by these controversies spans a wide range. Marginalized fans—especially Black ARMY members—have described feeling isolated and even pushed out by segments of the fandom. These experiences aren’t limited to online interactions. At live events, some fans have faced exclusion or differential treatment. Beyond race, similar stories have surfaced from fans in Southeast Asia, the Middle East, and other regions outside North America and Europe. The effect is clear: the promise of a global, unified ARMY is sometimes undermined by divisions along lines of race, nationality, or language.
Is the criticism of the BTS ARMY fair? The answer depends on where you look. The ARMY is an enormous, decentralized group—estimates put its active membership in the tens of millions. It is impossible to generalize about a single unified culture or attitude. There are countless examples of ARMYs confronting racism and supporting marginalized voices. In fact, many of the conversations around #BlackARMYsMatter were amplified by non-Black fans who recognized the importance of inclusion. Some ARMYs have created dedicated safe spaces, resources, and campaigns specifically aimed at supporting Black and POC fans. These efforts show genuine attempts to address the problem.
On the other hand, the persistence of discrimination and the frequency with which marginalized fans report backlash or dismissal show that the problem is ongoing and systemic, not incidental. The sheer size of the community means that even a small percentage of toxic or exclusionary behavior can have a massive impact. The repeated need for hashtags, statements, and campaigns signals that significant work remains.
Inside the fandom, debate continues over the best way to move forward. Some members advocate for stronger moderation in official and unofficial ARMY spaces, clearer codes of conduct, and more visible support from BTS and their management. Others worry that these efforts could divide the fandom, or claim that bringing up these issues publicly damages the group’s reputation. At the same time, there’s a growing recognition that silence—whether over racism, harassment, or even management controversies—allows problems to fester.
One thing is certain: the BTS ARMY is no longer just a fanclub. It’s a global community wrestling with what it means to be truly inclusive, ethical, and united. So the next time you see a hashtag trending worldwide, ask yourself: can a fandom this big ever live up to its own ideals—or are some divides just too deep to heal?