More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
The bodies were discovered just before midnight, on a quiet Sunday in Los Angeles. Nicole Brown Simpson lay at the foot of the steps outside her condominium, her head nearly severed from her body. Nearby, Ronald Goldman was sprawled motionless, his face battered, his torso and neck slashed with such force that blood covered the walkway and splattered the wall behind him. The brutality, the silence of the leafy Brentwood block, and the celebrity status of one of the people soon to be accused would spark a criminal investigation unlike any seen before in America.
Nicole Brown Simpson was born May 19, 1959, in Frankfurt, West Germany. She emigrated to the United States as a child, settling with her family in California. By the 1980s, Nicole was working as a waitress when she met O.J. Simpson, a former NFL star, television personality, and advertising icon. Simpson, already a household name, married Nicole in 1985. Their relationship was marked by both public adoration—lavish parties, red-carpet appearances—and private turmoil. Friends and family members later described years of emotional volatility and domestic violence within the marriage. Nicole filed for divorce in 1992, citing irreconcilable differences.
Ronald Goldman, born July 2, 1968, in Buffalo Grove, Illinois, moved to Los Angeles as a young adult. He worked as a waiter at Mezzaluna Trattoria, a restaurant in Brentwood, and aspired to become an actor. Described as athletic and outgoing, Goldman was known for his generosity and his circle of friends. On the night of June 12, 1994, he left Mezzaluna after his shift, planning to return a pair of eyeglasses that Nicole’s mother had left behind at the restaurant.
Nicole, in the weeks leading up to her murder, had confided to friends about her concerns regarding O.J. She reportedly planned to meet with Kris Jenner to discuss important matters regarding her relationship with her ex-husband, but never made it to that meeting. Nicole was raising her children in the Bundy Drive condominium, living a quieter life after her high-profile divorce, but she remained in frequent contact with O.J., who lived nearby in a mansion on Rockingham Avenue.
On the evening of June 12, Nicole dined with her children and family at Mezzaluna. Afterward, she returned home with her kids. Around 10:15 p.m., neighbors reported hearing a dog barking and plaintive cries, but nothing that drew immediate suspicion.
At 12:10 a.m. on June 13, neighbor Steven Schwab saw Nicole’s Akita wandering alone in the street. The dog’s paws and belly were stained with blood. Schwab, concerned, followed the dog back toward Nicole’s condominium, where he discovered the bodies of Nicole and Ronald Goldman. Police were called at 12:13 a.m.
Nicole’s body was found in a pool of blood at the base of the stairs leading to her front door. She had suffered 12 stab wounds. The fatal wound nearly decapitated her, severing her carotid artery and jugular vein. Defensive wounds on her hands and arms indicated she tried to fight off her attacker.
Ronald Goldman’s body was found nearby. He had been stabbed 20 times, primarily in the neck, chest, and abdomen. Goldman’s face was bruised, and there was evidence he had struggled fiercely before being killed. Blood spatter on the walls and walkway suggested a frantic, desperate fight.
Detectives Mark Fuhrman and Philip Vannatter arrived at the scene soon after. They noted a trail of bloody shoe prints leading away from the bodies. A left-hand leather glove, later matched to a pair found at the residence of O.J. Simpson, lay near Nicole’s body.
Police quickly began reconstructing the timeline. O.J. Simpson had left Los Angeles for Chicago on a late-night flight, departing just after 11 p.m. Investigators contacted Simpson in Chicago and informed him of Nicole’s death. He returned to Los Angeles the following day.
By June 17, suspicion had centered on O.J. Simpson. That afternoon, detectives visited his home on Rockingham Avenue. They discovered blood stains on the driveway and on the door handle of Simpson’s white Ford Bronco. A pair of socks stained with what appeared to be blood were found in his bedroom. Police also recovered the matching right-hand glove on Simpson’s property.
When police attempted to arrest Simpson that day, he failed to surrender. Instead, Simpson disappeared with his friend Al Cowlings, leading authorities on a now-famous low-speed pursuit across Los Angeles freeways. More than 95 million people watched the chase live on television as Cowlings drove the white Ford Bronco, with Simpson in the back seat, holding a gun and threatening self-harm. Police negotiators eventually convinced Simpson to surrender outside his Brentwood home, where he was taken into custody.
The investigation focused on forensic evidence found at the scene and in Simpson’s home. Crime scene analysts collected blood drops, hair, fibers, and the bloody gloves. The bloody footprints at the Bundy Drive scene were matched to a rare pair of Bruno Magli shoes. Only a small number of these Italian-made shoes were sold in the United States, and photographs would later emerge of Simpson wearing similar shoes at a public event.
A key piece of evidence was the DNA analysis of blood found at the crime scene, in Simpson’s Bronco, and at his home. Forensic testing indicated that the blood in these locations contained genetic markers matching Nicole Brown Simpson, Ronald Goldman, and O.J. Simpson. The odds of such a match occurring by chance were calculated by prosecution experts to be greater than one in several million.
Another crucial detail emerged from the autopsies. The pattern and depth of Nicole’s wounds indicated that her killer was likely right-handed, as the deepest cuts angled down from the right. Defensive wounds on Goldman’s hands and arms showed he had managed to grab the knife at some point, resulting in wounds to his own fingers and the attacker’s possible injury.
During the investigation, Dr. Henry Lee, a renowned forensic expert, examined the shoe print evidence at the crime scene. He testified that there were “two types of sole patterns” present, stating, “In addition to that shoewear evidence, I noticed a different design, a parallel design-type of pattern.” This raised the question of whether more than one person could have been present during the murders, though investigators ultimately focused on Simpson as the sole suspect.
On January 24, 1995, the criminal trial of O.J. Simpson began at the Los Angeles County Superior Court. The prosecution’s case relied on extensive forensic evidence: blood, hair, fibers, and the gloves. Marcia Clark and Christopher Darden led the prosecution. The defense was assembled by Robert Shapiro, Johnnie Cochran, F. Lee Bailey, Alan Dershowitz, and others—a team soon dubbed the "Dream Team" by the media.
The trial became a national obsession. Television cameras captured every moment, from opening statements to the smallest courtroom gesture. The prosecution emphasized the physical evidence: the bloody glove, the DNA matches, and Simpson’s apparent motive, rooted in years of abusive behavior toward Nicole. They argued that Simpson had driven to Nicole’s home on the night of June 12, confronted her, and killed both Nicole and Ronald Goldman in a rage.
The defense attacked the credibility of the police and the forensic process. They pointed to mishandled evidence, contaminated samples, and possible bias or misconduct by detectives, notably Mark Fuhrman. The defense famously had Simpson try on the bloody glove in court; Simpson struggled to fit the glove over his hand, leading to Johnnie Cochran’s memorable declaration, “If it doesn’t fit, you must acquit.”
The prosecution’s case was further complicated by lapses in police procedure. Several items of evidence—such as the socks, gloves, and blood samples—had not been properly photographed or preserved before being moved. Defense experts questioned the chain of custody for key evidence, suggesting possibilities for contamination or tampering.
One of the trial’s most significant moments came when Dr. Henry Lee testified about the shoe print evidence. He stated that he identified two different sole patterns at the crime scene. This detail complicated the prosecution’s argument that Simpson acted alone, though prosecutors contended that all other evidence pointed solely to Simpson.
On October 3, 1995, after less than four hours of deliberation, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty on both counts of murder. The decision shocked the nation. Simpson walked free, but the case was far from over.
In October 1996, the families of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman filed a civil lawsuit against Simpson for wrongful death. The civil trial began that same month, this time without the strict burden of proof required in a criminal case. In 1997, the jury found Simpson liable for the wrongful deaths of Nicole and Ronald. He was ordered to pay $33.5 million in damages—a sum equal to roughly $61 million today, adjusted for inflation. Simpson’s assets were subsequently targeted for collection, but much of the awarded money remained unpaid.
Forensic science played an outsized role in both trials. DNA evidence—still relatively new to the American court system in the mid-1990s—was subjected to intense scrutiny. Expert witnesses debated laboratory protocols, statistical probabilities, and the interpretation of mixed samples. The O.J. Simpson case introduced the broader public to concepts like allelic drop-out, random match probability, and the necessity of clean evidence handling.
The verdict’s aftermath led to ongoing debates about race, celebrity, media, and the legal system. The trial exposed deep fissures in perceptions of justice and police conduct, particularly between white and Black Americans. The televised proceedings, which routinely drew tens of millions of viewers, created a template for future high-profile cases and launched the careers of multiple attorneys and commentators.
A lesser-known detail from the case concerns Nicole’s final days. Shortly before her death, she planned to meet Kris Jenner to discuss ongoing concerns about her relationship with O.J. Simpson. That meeting never took place, and what Nicole intended to share remains unknown.
The lasting pain of the crime was expressed by Nicole’s sister, Denise Brown, who said, “The pain doesn’t go away, it doesn’t subside, doesn’t get easier. But you do the best you can and you move on.”
Despite the acquittal in criminal court, the civil verdict and the weight of forensic evidence convinced many that Simpson was responsible for the murders. Some legal analysts have pointed to Dr. Henry Lee’s observation about two different shoe prints as a detail that still prompts questions about the possibility of another party’s involvement, though no further suspects were successfully prosecuted.
The O.J. Simpson case revealed the power and limitations of forensic evidence in criminal trials. It demonstrated how celebrity influence, media saturation, and doubts about institutional fairness could shape public opinion and jury outcomes. The use of televised trials—still rare at the time—transformed the American legal system’s relationship to the public and the press.
On June 12, 1994, two people were murdered with a brutality that stunned Los Angeles. Twelve stab wounds for Nicole Brown Simpson, nearly decapitating her. Twenty for Ronald Goldman. One pair of shoe prints, then a second, and a trail of blood that led from Bundy Drive to the white Ford Bronco parked on Rockingham Avenue.