More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
If you ask a room full of Fire Emblem fans to name the most controversial character choices and moments in the franchise, you'll get a hundred different answers and probably start at least three arguments. This ranking will ruffle feathers: these are the top five Fire Emblem character inclusions and story choices that sent the fandom into debate mode, from Super Smash Bros. drama to meme-fueled upsets, recurring accusations of favoritism, and even a voice actor scandal.
Number 5: Byleth’s Smash Bros. Backlash.
Byleth debuted as the customizable protagonist of Fire Emblem: Three Houses in 2019. Intelligent Systems and Nintendo designed Byleth to serve as both a story character and a player avatar, with a name, gender, and birthday all chosen by the player. Byleth’s story role in Three Houses saw them become a professor at Garreg Mach Monastery and eventually, depending on the route, inherit supernatural powers from the goddess Sothis. Just months after Three Houses released, Nintendo announced that Byleth would be joining Super Smash Bros. Ultimate as a DLC fighter in January 2020. This decision meant Byleth would become the eighth Fire Emblem character in Smash Bros. Ultimate, outnumbering most other franchises in the game’s roster.
The backlash was immediate and widespread. The criticism focused on the perceived overrepresentation of Fire Emblem characters in Smash Bros. and the addition of yet another sword-wielding protagonist. In a ResetEra poll from June 2021, Byleth was voted the most boring Fighters Pass character, pulling in over half the votes for the least interesting DLC. Western fans were especially vocal, with some calling Byleth’s inclusion unnecessary, while others appreciated having a representative from the newest Fire Emblem title. Even Masahiro Sakurai, Smash Bros. creator, admitted publicly, “there are too many Fire Emblem characters,” though he clarified he didn’t personally make the DLC selections. Nintendo tried to blunt criticism by giving Byleth a unique moveset featuring not just the Sword of the Creator, but also the signature weapons of Claude, Dimitri, and Edelgard from Three Houses. Still, the announcement video’s YouTube dislike count soared, and the debate over Byleth’s place in Smash Bros. remains one of the franchise’s most visible controversies.
Number 4: Gatekeeper’s Fan-Fueled Ascent.
Gatekeeper began as a generic, unnamed NPC in Fire Emblem: Three Houses, introduced in 2019. His entire role was to stand guard at the entrance to Garreg Mach Monastery, greeting Byleth with an enthusiastic “Greetings, Professor! Nothing to report!” Despite—or because of—his minor status, fans latched onto Gatekeeper’s sincere enthusiasm, turning him into a meme and propelling his catchphrase into fanart, commentary, and even requests for romance options. Writer Petrana Radulovic at Polygon called for Gatekeeper to be added as a playable character, citing the groundswell of affection for his positive outlook during the game’s otherwise tense narrative. By 2021, Gatekeeper rode this meme wave to an upset victory in Fire Emblem Heroes’ "Choose Your Legends" poll, earning more votes than established main characters like Marth and Chrom. He won by almost double the votes of the runner-up in the male category.
That win led to controversy within Fire Emblem’s passionate fanbase. Gatekeeper, a character with almost no story significance and only a handful of voiced lines, was added to the mobile game Fire Emblem Heroes before many longstanding protagonists. Some fans celebrated the outcome as a triumph of fan engagement and meme culture, while others argued Gatekeeper’s spot should have gone to a more developed, story-driven character. Sisi Jiang at Kotaku described his win as “out of place” but praised how much effort went into his combat design for Heroes. The debate over Gatekeeper’s inclusion is a pure example of how Fire Emblem’s fandom can elevate a background NPC to legendary status, then immediately argue over whether it was deserved.
Number 3: Lyn and the Debate Over Representation.
Lyn made her international debut in Fire Emblem: The Blazing Blade, released outside Japan in 2003. She was the first female lead in the series to be featured internationally and quickly became a fan favorite, with her blue-trimmed outfit, long green hair, and tragic Lorca tribe backstory. Designed by Sachiko Wada and voiced by Makiko Ōmoto in Japanese and Wendee Lee in English, Lyn’s early popularity was so unexpected that Fire Emblem Heroes co-director Kouhei Maeda later said her support “surprised” the development team, especially outside Japan.
Lyn’s high profile across crossover titles and merchandise stirred up controversy about perceived favoritism. She consistently placed at the top of Fire Emblem Heroes popularity polls, earning more than five alternate versions in the game. In 2017, Lyn received the highest number of votes for any female character in the game’s fan poll. She appears in Fire Emblem Engage as an “Emblem” character and has a prominent assist trophy role in the Super Smash Bros. series. Some fans argue that Lyn’s frequent inclusion overshadows other deserving characters, calling attention to gaps in representation for protagonists from less-promoted Fire Emblem games. Critics at Nintendo World Report called Lyn “bland” and pointed to her limited impact on the main plot of The Blazing Blade. Still, her presence in crossover content and her early role as a female lead keep Lyn at the center of debates over character selection, representation, and nostalgia-driven favoritism.
Number 2: Three Houses’ Divisive Story Routes.
Fire Emblem: Three Houses, released in 2019, introduced a branching narrative format that let players choose between four story routes—each led by one of the main house leaders: Edelgard, Dimitri, Claude, or the Church of Seiros. The choice dramatically impacts the events, alliances, and endgame, leading to radically different experiences. These routes are known as Crimson Flower, Azure Moon, Verdant Wind, and Silver Snow. Each route explores different themes, with Edelgard’s Crimson Flower route, in particular, focusing on rebellion against the Church and the implications of breaking tradition.
The introduction of multiple story routes sparked heated debate among fans about which path is morally justified and which can be considered canon. Edelgard’s actions, as the Flame Emperor declaring war on the church, ignited especially passionate arguments. TheGamer described her as “one of the most complex characters in Fire Emblem history,” with her supporters defending her anti-authoritarian stance, and detractors labeling her a villain. Other fans argue over whether Byleth’s default alignment should be neutrality, alliance with Edelgard, or support for the Church. As of the most recent reporting, no route is officially canon, leaving the debate unresolved. The structure of Three Houses turned the question of “which path is right?” into a permanent part of Fire Emblem’s online discourse.
Number 1: Voice Actor Controversies.
In July 2019, Fire Emblem’s fandom was rocked by a real-world controversy when Chris Niosi, the original English voice actor for male Byleth, faced allegations of violating a non-disclosure agreement and admitted on social media to physical, emotional, and sexual abuse. Nintendo and Intelligent Systems responded by removing Niosi from the role and replacing him with Zach Aguilar. All of Niosi’s lines in Fire Emblem: Three Houses were re-recorded ahead of release, a rare and public move by a major publisher. The recasting extended to Byleth’s appearances in Fire Emblem Heroes and Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.
The situation generated strong reactions across the fanbase. Some players welcomed Nintendo’s quick action in response to the allegations, seeing it as a necessary step for accountability. Others raised questions about the speed and transparency of the process, and whether similar standards would be applied to controversies involving other voice actors or production staff. The scandal also led to discussions about the role of individual creators in shaping beloved characters, how fandoms respond to allegations, and what responsibility game companies have to their audiences. This incident stands out because it directly affected the voice and identity of a main protagonist across multiple games, with visible, lasting consequences in every new appearance of Byleth.
If you think a character, story choice, or moment got snubbed from this ranking—or if the order has you ready to log on and argue—let us know your top five Fire Emblem controversies.