More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
This is “The Dark Side of Genshin Impact’s Global Fandom.”
Genshin Impact exploded onto the gaming scene in September 2020, developed by miHoYo, and it’s easy to see why millions got hooked. The game offers a sprawling open world inspired by real cultures, with breathtaking visuals, orchestral soundtracks recorded in London and Shanghai, and a constant stream of updates. Players rave about the diverse cast of over 70 playable characters, each with unique elemental powers and backstories. Cosplayers flock to conventions as favorites like Hu Tao and Zhongli. On social media, Genshin’s fan artists and meme-makers have built a creative boom, with some fan art posts racking up over 100,000 likes in just hours. The game’s gacha system, which lets fans “wish” for rare characters, fuels anticipation and community excitement with every new update. In just its first year, Genshin Impact grossed over $1 billion on mobile devices alone, surpassing the annual revenue of established franchises like Pokémon GO and Candy Crush Saga.
But while Genshin Impact’s fandom is celebrated for its passion and creativity, it has also become notorious for its intense internal conflicts and waves of harassment. The game’s global popularity means that cultural, linguistic, and social divides between fans often erupt into bitter arguments. Disputes over shipping—debating which characters should be paired romantically—have led to doxing attacks and mass reporting sprees, particularly on platforms like Twitter and Discord. Some fans have gone so far as to spam negative reviews on the App Store and Google Play when their favorite characters receive what they see as unfair treatment or nerfs. Allegations of racism and colorism have fueled further controversy, with fans criticizing the lighter skin tones of new characters released in updates themed on regions inspired by Africa and South Asia.
The roots of this tension go back to the game’s meteoric global expansion. As miHoYo rolled out updates for regions like Inazuma, Sumeru, and Fontaine—each based loosely on real-world cultures—fans from those backgrounds began calling out perceived misrepresentation and stereotyping. In 2022, when the Sumeru region debuted with a cast of mostly light-skinned characters inspired by Middle Eastern and South Asian themes, social media campaigns with hashtags like #SumeruSoWhite trended worldwide. Players posted side-by-side comparisons of in-game models and real cultural attire, arguing that the game erased darker skin and authentic features. The controversy sparked open letters with tens of thousands of signatures demanding more inclusive character design. Meanwhile, defenders argued that the game is a fantasy and should not be held to real-world standards.
This divide has affected a wide circle of people. Content creators who voice nuanced criticism of miHoYo’s design decisions have faced coordinated harassment campaigns and, in some cases, threats of violence. Artists drawing fanworks for ships considered “problematic” by parts of the community have received targeted abuse, with some reporting being doxed and driven off social media. Cosplayers have also faced backlash for portraying characters of different races or genders, igniting further debates about cultural appropriation and “blackfishing.” Even voice actors for Genshin Impact have become targets when they interact with perceived “rival” ships or joke about game lore.
Is the criticism of Genshin Impact’s fandom fair? Many observers point to the size and diversity of the player base—over 60 million registered users globally by 2023—as a factor that magnifies every dispute. Some fans insist the toxicity is driven by a vocal minority, while the majority are simply passionate about the game and its world. However, when harassment incidents become national news in countries like the United States, China, and Indonesia, it’s clear that the problem is not isolated. In March 2022, a Genshin Impact-themed Discord server with over 200,000 members temporarily shut down after moderators received hundreds of threats over a shipping poll result. The escalation of online arguments into real-world consequences shows that, for some, the line between fiction and personal identity is thin.
The community remains sharply divided over how to address these problems. Some call for greater moderation and zero-tolerance bans on harassment, but others worry about censorship and limiting free creative expression. There are ongoing debates about whether miHoYo should involve more cultural consultants for future updates, or if fans’ expectations for accuracy are unrealistic for a fantasy game. Others urge fellow players to “touch grass”—lingo for taking a break from online drama and remembering that, at its core, Genshin Impact is just a game. Yet with each new patch and character release, old wounds reopen and new feuds flare up, particularly as the fandom grows and the stakes of online reputation and influence rise.
What is the future of Genshin Impact’s global fandom? Can a community so large and diverse ever find common ground, or will each new update spark another round of bitter conflict? And as more games follow Genshin’s model, will these controversies become the new normal for global online fandoms?